Best All Around Catcher's Mitts

For Advanced High School, College & Pro Players

cropped result

All Star

All Star Pro Elite 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$450

5

Specs

Extra Stiff
Steerhide Leather

cropped result

Rawlings

Rawlings Heart of the Hide 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$300

5

Specs

Extra Stiff
Steerhide Leather

cropped result

Wilson

Wilson A2000 CM33 33" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$300

4.5

Specs

A2000
Pro Stock Leather
Stiff

cropped result

Rawlings

Rawlings Pro Preferred 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$380

4.5

Specs

Extra Stiff
Steerhide Leather

cropped result

Nokona

Nokona X2 Elite 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$480

4

Specs

Soft
Kangaroo Leather

Best Catcher's Mitts for the Cost

For High School & College Players

cropped result

Wilson

Wilson A2000 SuperSkin M1D 33.5" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$260

4.5

Specs

Pro Stock Leather
Stiff
A2000

cropped result

All Star

All Star Pro 35" Baseball Catcher's Mitt

$230

4

Specs

Soft
Steerhide Leather

cropped result

Mizuno

Mizuno Pro Select 33.5" Catcher's Mitt

$250

4

Specs

Stiff
Steerhide Leather

How to Choose the Right Catcher's Mitt

When selecting a catcher's mitt, prioritize pocket depth, as a deeper pocket provides better control and reduces pop-outs. Mitt size ranges from 32" to 34", with larger sizes offering more surface area but potentially slowing transfer times. Webbing is key—closed web designs offer more support, especially for fast pitches. Consider break-in time; high-quality leather mitts mold to your hand but need more time to break in.

Materials for Catcher's Mitts

  • Steerhide: Durable and holds shape well.
  • Kangaroo Leather: Lightweight yet strong.
  • Cowhide: Quicker break-in, ideal for comfort.

Pro Features for Catcher's Mitts

Look for reinforced palm padding for protection, moisture-wicking linings to stay dry, and quick transfer designs to improve game speed.

Maintaining Your Catcher's Mitt

Regularly condition the mitt to keep it soft and prevent cracking. Store it properly in a cool, dry place to maintain its shape. Break it in with oil, light use, and glove mallets for the best fit.

Catcher’s Mitt Sizing

Sizes range from 32" to 34". Smaller mitts suit younger players for quick handling, while larger ones provide extra reach for older players catching fast pitches.

Similar Posts:

Join the club!

Sign up for our newsletter for more articles like this and features updates from our team!

logo

2023 - baseballnearyou.com